Magnifying Dissent: “Illuminating” the Capital Appeals Process through Abolitionist Literacy Narrative

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.21623/1.13.1.3

Keywords:

Death row, Dissent, Capital appeals process, Abolitionist narratives, Grammars of law, Illumination

Abstract

In 1994, Joesph Patri Brown was convicted of capital murder in Mississippi, and he has been fighting that conviction from death row ever since. In this article, Brown and co-author Alison Turner frame his experiences of learning and marking the capital appeals process as an abolitionist literacy narrative. They position the capital appeals process as an esoteric genre that consists of both text—volumes and volumes of documents written in legalese—but also, like any genre, context. Joesph shares pieces of his narrative that include his early “illiteracy” in what happens to people on death row; his endurance of that process; his learning of “legalese”; and methods for staying involved in his own case. Alison connects each of these sections to abolitionist writing studies discourse, engaging most closely with scholars Dan Berger, Mariame Kaba, and David Stein, who propose that abolitionist work “reduce[s] the power of an oppressive system while illuminating the system’s inability to solve the crises it creates” (n.p.). The article contributes not only a focus on the capital appeals process within the discourse of prison writing and what Joe Lockard calls “death row narratives” (60) but also a specific tool for reading the capital appeals process—“magnifying dissent.” Brown and Turner show how “magnifying dissent” is a specific practice of counterstory (Martinez) for abolitionist “illuminating.”

Author Biographies

Joesph Patri Brown, Death Row, Unit 17, Mississippi State Penitentiary, Parchman

Joesph Patri Brown is of Black and Natchez Indian descent and was born on the river in Natchez, Mississippi. For the past three decades, he has been challenging his wrongful conviction of capital murder. He writes in multiple and hybrid genres, including thought pieces, short fiction, letters, and memoir, and is the author of The Image They Had Painted (PS Guelph 2026).

Alison Turner, University of South Dakota

Alison Turner is a community-engaged writer, researcher, and oral historian. Her scholarly work appears in American Indian Quarterly, Callaloo, Oral History Review, and American Archivist, among other journals. She has a PhD in Literary Studies from the University of Denver and was a 2022-24 American Council of Learned Societies Leading Edge Postdoctoral Fellow in Jackson, Mississippi. She is Assistant Professor of Practice at the University of South Dakota, and the Curator of the South Dakota Oral History Center.

Downloads

Published

2026-11-17

How to Cite

Brown, J. P., & Turner, A. (2026). Magnifying Dissent: “Illuminating” the Capital Appeals Process through Abolitionist Literacy Narrative. Literacy in Composition Studies, 13(1), 40–59. https://doi.org/10.21623/1.13.1.3